The other set will hold the prizes! I am all about free prizes too by the way. 🙂
What I do, is throughout the day randomly I grab an egg from the student basket (I sometimes even have a student go get me one) and see whose name it is. If that person is on task/following directions/etc I say their name outloud. They then get to pick a RANDOM egg from the prize basket! Whatever is in their basket is what they get. They don’t get to put it back. IF the student I pulled is not ready to earn their prize, I don’t announce their name. I say something like, “Darn! This person isn’t quite ready to earn their prize yet.”I then put their egg back in the basket for them to earn it later.